17 November 2026

Mr TIM JAMES (Willoughby) (12:51): My question is directed to the Minister for Better Regulation and Fair Trading. Yesterday, amid a worsening housing market due to Labor's toxic taxes, the Premier announced a policy backflip and abandoned the Minister's laws restricting real estate agents from lowering advertised property prices. If the Premier has lost confidence—

The SPEAKER: Members will remain silent while the member for Willoughby asks his question. They can interject afterwards.

Mr TIM JAMES: If the Premier has lost confidence in the Minister's signature reform, why should the people of New South Wales have confidence in him as a Minister?

Mr Greg Warren: Point of order—

Mr Ron Hoenig: Point of order—

The SPEAKER: I was going to give the call to the member for Campbelltown, but I think he will defer to the Leader of the House on the point of order.

Mr Ron Hoenig: The question infringes on Standing Order 128 (2) in that it contains argument, inference and ironical expression, if not expression of opinion. It should be ruled out of order and the member should rewrite it in a proper way.

The SPEAKER: I have the standing orders in front of me. That is one of my favourites. I uphold the point of order. I will give the member for Willoughby the opportunity to restate his question so that it is in order. If he is prepared to do that now, I will invite the member to ask his question. Otherwise, I will return to him at a later time.

Mr TIM JAMES: My question is directed to the Minister for Better Regulation and Fair Trading.

The SPEAKER: I call the member for Bankstown to order for the first time.

Mr TIM JAMES: Yesterday, amid a worsening housing market, the Premier announced a policy change and abandoned the laws that the Minister brought forward to this House that would have restricted real estate agents from lowering advertised property prices. Given that the Premier has abandoned those reforms, should the people of New South Wales not abandon him as the Minister?

Mr Greg Warren: Point of order—

Mr Ron Hoenig: Point of order—

The SPEAKER: Members will come to order. I will hear the point of order from the Leader of the House.

Mr Ron Hoenig: The last part of the member's question contains argument, imputation, ironical expression, an expression of opinion and a hypothetical matter. He should either ask the question properly or the question should be ruled out of order.

Ms Felicity Wilson: To the point of order—

The SPEAKER: Members will come to order. I am sure they will find this discussion illuminating.

Ms Felicity Wilson: It is perfectly appropriate for a question to be put to a Minister about whether they should remain a Minister of the Crown when there are questions about that. This question has been put to Ministers from every party in this Parliament over its history. The Minister should be given the opportunity to defend himself, even if his Government does not want him to.

The SPEAKER: I do not uphold the point of order. Members will come to order. I am capable of ruling on the matter. I heard the Leader of the House and I am close to upholding his point of order. However, I must consider not only whether the question is in order but also whether the Minister wishes to answer it.

Mr Anoulack Chanthivong: I'm happy to.

The SPEAKER: That being the case, the Minister has the call. I call the member for Bathurst to order for the first time.

Mr ANOULACK CHANTHIVONG (Macquarie Fields—Minister for Better Regulation and Fair Trading, Minister for Industry and Trade, Minister for Innovation, Science and Technology, Minister for Building, and Minister for Corrections) (12:55): I thank the shadow Minister for his question. The hallmark of this Minns Labor Government is that we are reasonable, we are pragmatic and we are always listening to stakeholders from every angle.

The SPEAKER: I call the member for Myall Lakes to order for the first time.

Mr ANOULACK CHANTHIVONG: Whether someone is an individual or part of an association or an industry group, it does not matter. Their voice counts all the time. That listening does not stop once legislation has passed.

The SPEAKER: I call the member for Terrigal to order for the second time. I call the member for Goulburn to order for the third time.

Mr ANOULACK CHANTHIVONG: It is an ongoing journey and an ongoing consultation process, because that is what a mature, reasonable government does. That is what people expect and that is what the Government has done. However difficult it is, a good, focused government will always make the decision that is in the best interests of the people of New South Wales. I also clarify some facts on this. The laws have been paused for 12 months. Underquoting is still illegal. I wanted to make those points. Underquoting, as everyone knows, is much more prevalent in a rising, hot market.

The SPEAKER: I call the member for Newtown to order for the first time.

Mr ANOULACK CHANTHIVONG: In all fairness, anybody who has been reading any publication or following any news or commentary will have seen that the circumstances were very different. Members opposite are talking to the media and have started bagging out the laws. But what did they do when the laws were debated? Let me remind the good folk on the other side what they did. They actually voted for the legislation. On top of that, they moved no amendments to the underquoting aspects of it. So here we are. They have tramped in here to make opportunistic statements. Let me read from what the shadow Minister said. The first words of the member for Willoughby in debate on the underquoting bill were, "The Coalition will support this bill."

The SPEAKER: Members will come to order.

Mr ANOULACK CHANTHIVONG: Of course, those are the same words that were used by almost every member. They all said, "The Coalition will support this bill"—in the lower House, in the upper House and out in public. The hallmark of this Minns Labor Government is that we are reasonable, we are pragmatic and we will always listen.

The SPEAKER: Order! I call the member for Bega. He will be heard in silence.